Author : J. V. Hodgkinson F. C. A. Chartered Accountant : August 2006 to January 2012 FLOOD PROOFING BRISBANE from damaging floods to the point of extinction. MITIGATING flooding in Ipswich and Gympie. Putting REAL MEANING into "Drought proofing SEQ" Preliminary view of our main water supply. To emphasize its importance it appears at the heading in all pages in this web site The relationship of the Wivenhoe/Somerset dam system to its rainfall in the catchments has been quite different from the way it has been presented to us since the joint dams’ inception in 1986. The main rainfall supplying our water is the, season ignoring, rain depressions in the form of Cyclones, Monsoons and large scale rain depressions. They generally cover the whole of South East Queensland at the same time. They provide much more water than our December to March “wet season” which is well known to us. Mr Rob Drury of SEQWater drew our attention
to this in his Courier Mail article of the 10th Mr Drury called these rainfall events
“uncommon events”. Bureau of Meteorology flood
This is my review based on official
statistics and documents. These statistics and documents are presented to you so
that you can arrive at your own conclusions. ************************************************************ |
|
|
May 2009 *************************************************************** There have been refinements made in the meantime to further illustrate the importance of these events and also the fact that they are not so "uncommon". These refinements are "frequency of Uncommon events" (second picture); Updating of the Wivehoe dam level graph (First picture with wide border) and; Analysis of the May low pressure system (third picture) and; Years to fill the dams by the various sources available (fourth picture). Together they provide concrete evidence that "uncommon events" are our main water supply and a great volume of flood water currently goes over the dam walls.
********************************************************
The importance of uncommon events was articulated by
From this we perceive that there are two types of rainfall in the catchments. They are the normal rain that we receive year after year and "uncommon events". The uncommon events can fill the dams in a few days whereas normal summer rainfall takes around 9 years to fill. One of the principal objectives of this section is to examine the frequency of these events. The matters in that article relating to uncommon events are the following :-
Summer rainfall This aspect has been examined in detail in the "Summer V Non Sum" button. All rainfall stations are detailed and confirm the 50 percent for the life of the Bureau of Meteorology records. As explained in that section, it makes it convenient in our examination to select the Summer months. We will now examine the Summer rains for both dams from 1910 to 2006. Prior to 1910 the Somerset was reduced to one rainfall station and might have proved unreliable back past that date.
Both of these graphs are based on the same gradients and are visually comparable. The "thumb nails" show the rainfall variances at a glance. High Rainfall requirements. The article lists specific requirements of rainfall. They are 300mm to 350mm in the Wivenhoe and 350mm to 400mm in the Somerset. It is required over a period of just a few days. The following are listings for both dams over the period 1898 to 2006. They are for a full month. Therefore the month must be equal to, or more than, the uncommon event requirement. As required in the article, the rainfalls listed are for the whole of the catchments.
Frequency In the Twentieth Century the frequency of these "uncommon events" were : 1988-1999, 5 in 12 years : 1971-1974, 4 in a tight group : 1955 and 1956 : 1927 and 1928 : 1910. Conclusion to this point Five major groups in the Twentieth Century devolves to 20 years apart. There are many other minor events we will consider later in this web site when assessing the feasibility of harnessing their surplus water. A detailed analysis of the Rainfall Stations listed in the article together with the Bureau of Meteorology data for their full period will follow at the end of this section. You will then be in an ideal position to compare the last 21 years 1986 to 2006 with the remainder of the 108 years 1898 to 1985. Five uncommon events including 1992 and 1999 These events are listed in the Courier Mail article. They are best
The specific mention of of 1992 and 1999 clearly indicates the amount of water lost over the spillway in these two events as well as the others with the 1996 event being the exception. An analysis of all the base data of all the rainfall stations in the Wivenhoe and Somerset Dams now follows. The base data from which it is drawn is in the "Rain 1986 to 2006" button. SEQWater has pinpointed the events in 1992 and 1999. The single month requirements of 350mm in the Somerset and 300mm in the Wivenhoe are more than adequately covered in all five events. We see in this period 1986, being the start of Wivenhoe, to February 2001 at least 5 of these rare events. They filled the Dams from Scratch in the Wivenhoe's case to flood mode in 1999 and February 2001. This was done in the face of the steady but high population growth as outlined above. To do this requires surplus water well beyond our needs for 12 years. Detailed frequency of events of the past and possible future occurrences.
The events of the Twentieth Century are quite different to the events of the latter part of the Nineteenth Century. A view of it follows.
Latter part of the Nineteenth Century This gauge heights of floods registered at Brisbane City are a
guide to floods in the A more detailed examination of the "uncommon events" of both of these centuries is conducted when consideration is given later in this web site to harnessing the surplus water from these events.
FINAL CONCLUSION The importance of Uncommon Events in filling Dams has been adequately demonstrated and SEQWater statement is confirmed. We have touched on the variations between centuries and seen the infrequent occurrence in the Twentieth Century. We have not as yet examined the minor variations of these major events. This will be concluded when the feasibility of harnessing of these events is considered later in this web site.
Individual Rainfall Stations highlighted by SEQWater article in Courier Mail 10/02/2007 These particular Rainfall Stations were highlighted by I have summarised the "uncommon events" of these three Stations and inserted the Bureau of Meteorology data so that you may make your own assessment. The data goes back to 1893 in some cases. I have added the "Somerset Dam Rainfall Station" for balance.
Esk Post Office Kilcoy
|